Personally I think we should have gotten rid of the effigy a long time ago. Or it gives a double xp bonus for a week or something. The pattern of strongest city wins CTF, gets stronger by being even more attractive for the next six months is tiring.
The CTF is a fun game, but does it really need any more of a reward than bragging rights, maybe some sort of shiny statue for the city.
Except that Nature's very much an enemy of Targossas as well. Unless you really want to amnesia-dust them murdering your denizens for blood rituals, raiding, blowing tanks in your city, writing posts threatening to destroy you, etc. Amnesia-dust RP ftw
Except that Nature's very much an enemy of Targossas as well. Unless you really want to amnesia-dust them murdering your denizens for blood rituals, raiding, blowing tanks in your city, writing posts threatening to destroy you, etc. Amnesia-dust RP ftw
Incorrect.
Targossas is (vaguely) an ideological enemy of Eleusis (because it's a city, because Deucora blasted a hole in the ER, blah blah). Not the other way around. We're enemies of convenience. Unless Targ suddenly decides nuking the forests on the daily is what is best for Creation, the Eleusis-Targ relationship will likely never be as horribly irreconcilable as the Eleusis-Mhaldor relationship.
A frenzied cleric screams, "Like more than one halo!"
Generally, realistic characters and factions take being constantly attacked and threatened with extermination as a reason to hold someone as an enemy, too.
Targ is getting blasted a lot even though their ideology pretty much says "even if you have to do bad things and break laws to weaken evil/chaos do it".
What about the Eleusians who accepted the help/offer?
'Vying' = the last speaker and the current one? As far as I know, there's only one Hierophant that hasn't been an enemy of Targ in a while, too.
Yeah, there's a historical basis for them winning if they help each other... And Mhaldor/Ashtan were basically completely unbeatable when they were together, yet they drifted apart based on conscious decisions made by the players that that wasn't good for the game and made for less interesting RP. Part of the annoyance here is that Targossas only pays lipservice to the unspoken agreement of 'every city for itself' that's been the norm for years.
If that's the way they choose to play it. But, and I say this OOC, Targossas has a very slimy feel to it. It doesn't feel like the city of Good. It's...I don't know. Pretending to be Good? I mean one thing that pervades all good factions in general is that they're honest, upright, and principled. Targossas is more...the ends justify the means.
Late and off topic, but since I feel the need to point out...as @Quisse said, that perfectly describes what Targossas -should- be. It's not Shallam, and 100% about the ends justifying the means. So I'm glad to hear they're at least succeeding in that regard :pleased:
As for the rest of the complaints about OOC boundaries and shit, well, I'll pretty much just echo what @Halos said. Whether or not it was an asshole thing to do OOCly, it was a perfectly acceptable move by IC standards.
And @Aegoth, Eleusis isn't an enemy. More accurately, Eleusis sees us as an enemy, but we see them essentially as people trying to do the right thing and going about it in a mildly wrong way. Unlike Mhaldor who we see as a group of people trying to do the right thing (technically the 1st Truth is about growth of creation and all, for those who didn't know) but going about it an incredibly wrong and screwed up way that does more harm than good. Hence why it would be seen as a lesser evil to let Eleusis win rather than let Mhaldor win.
Man, Mhaldor really can't deal with losing at all, can they?
It's CTF, which is a game. It's not like it's "Ideologically pure City-versus-City conflict." People've always done slightly questionable things during Y700 events that really shouldn't ever be taken as the measure of a City's actual stance/position. I'm one hundred percent fine with Targossas helping Mhaldor lose a CTF. Wouldn't be okay with Targossas fighting a war for Eleusis (which it hasn't, and won't).
And it's funny to see that some of you, whom I very distinctly remember have taken dives to not gain points in order to just mess with others' chances to win CTFs throughout the year, whining so hard about the shoe being on the other foot. Pretty much everyone here, in some alt or another, I'm sure, has actually done that to another faction, so, forreal, take it easy.
Honestly, it wasn't Targossas. It was Tesha and maybe a few people who were defending Shastaan, potentially without even realizing it was Eleusis' flag at the time (we had Shastaan for the entire CTF before then). Eleusis was still attacking Tesha on sight.
Arguing about whether a motivation is acceptable or not isn't going to be particularly beneficial, because we all play characters in different factions. Perspective is highly important. I'm getting that from Mhaldor's perspective it was entirely unjustifiable IC because they don't see Mhaldor as being any more of an enemy to Targossas than Eleusis. Targossas doesn't really seem to get how it isn't obvious that Eleusis is far less of an enemy compared to Mhaldor.
The thing is, arguing about what's right and wrong isn't going to get anywhere. Sometimes it's best to just agree to disagree, and there doesn't seem like there's going to be any changing Mhaldor's mind or Targossas' mind. And that's okay. I just hope they don't think it's out of OOC hatred or anything like that, it's fine if they think the reasoning is flawed, though.
I think that believing people hate you/your faction OOCly would be really unhealthy, and that it would probably lead to behavior that isn't particularly great. At the end of the day it's important to remember that it's just a game, and try not to feel like IC actions mean ill OOC feelings, much less were motivated by such. It's probably naive to hope that the majority of such a small community can be friends, but at the very least I hope there aren't any lingering feelings of OOC animosity.
This was my first CTF and I did not know what to expect! It was very messy half the time because there were so many people to hit but I think I enjoyed the experience. Despite having access to all other skills, I feel like I was overwhelmed with what I could do and fell back into using the skills I was most familiar with.
Whoever dropped all those holocausts while phased, they really hurt! And I hope I will never find myself in the same room as Jarrod and Crixos. They locked me so fast that I did not even have the chance to run.
Man, Mhaldor really can't deal with losing at all, can they?
These are pretty much the only kind of comments I have protested against in the whole of the thread (the above, the "petulant" comments, etc). Everything else I've discussed fairly level-headedly. I disagree with what Targossas did (and yes, Tesha, you do represent your city in such a large event, even if it wasn't a complete city-wide effort) did (obviously), but it's their decision to make.
But srs, there's really nothing else left to discuss. The divine of Targ at least support it, I imagine Eleusian ones don't give a damn, ours is busy building a brothel deep in the Inferno, and Mhaldor will just have to try for their first CTF win another time.
Edit: I am all for discussion of crazy skills and logs, mind. I wish I had more time to play with things. I didn't even get to check out much except that I have 44% devotion left still.
Edit edit: I'm so tired, what is english.
And I love too Be still, my indelible friend That love soon might end You are unbreaking And be known in its aching Though quaking Shown in this shaking Though crazy Lately of my wasteland, baby That's just wasteland, baby
I'd like to also point out that I spent the last 15 minutes trying to take an Eleusian flag because I had no idea we were helping them. Also, true wracking dsl combos what?
@Tesha always has the worst plans, and NO one should ever listen to them.
..especially not Tesha.
I don't know, some of them had a certain flair.
I forgot I could evade out of gravehands in the "I love you" log from Tharos, too. Actually, I forgot I could evade repeatedly. I guess dirge went to my head a bit, because I was having far too much fun making gravehands go away.
- (Eleusis): Ellodin says, "The Fissure of Echoes is Sarathai's happy place." - With sharp, crackling tones, Kyrra tells you, "The ladies must love you immensely." - (Eleusian Ranger Techs): Savira says, "Most of the hard stuff seem to have this built in code like: If adventurer_hitting_me = "Sarathai" then send("terminate and selfdestruct")." - Makarios says, "Serve well and perish." - Xaden says, "Xaden confirmed scrub 2017."
Except that Nature's very much an enemy of Targossas as well. Unless you really want to amnesia-dust them murdering your denizens for blood rituals, raiding, blowing tanks in your city, writing posts threatening to destroy you, etc. Amnesia-dust RP ftw
Eleusis isn't an enemy of Creation, which is what Targossas cares about. They're at most an annoyance that sometimes distracts us from doing the important work of countering Evil, Darkness and Chaos, there's not really a need for us to do anything except ignore them unless they give us a reason to.
That's just it though, they put a decent amount of effort into giving you a reason to. I saw lots of them trying to escalate conflict, and lots of Targ trying to avoid it.
Cascades of quicksilver light streak across the firmament as the celestial voice of Ourania intones, "Oh Jarrod..."
That's just it though, they put a decent amount of effort into giving you a reason to. I saw lots of them trying to escalate conflict, and lots of Targ trying to avoid it.
Thing is surely they'd have to outevil and destroy mhaldor for them to rate a mention against Targossas though?
ICly, who gives a damn? They're pissed off that a river was diverted, some forest may have been destroyed, and we're building with bricks and stone and other materials rather than living in a tree. When you're opposing three factions that are trying to pervert the very nature of Creation that sort of pales in comparison, especially when their attacks don't actually work against your goal at all.
That's just it though, they put a decent amount of effort into giving you a reason to. I saw lots of them trying to escalate conflict, and lots of Targ trying to avoid it.
Targ did make a couple of raids on Eleusis during that period. Just off
the top of my head, there was one lengthy brawl that I missed, another
that resulted in a couple of fishing rooms destroyed, and then that
really fun one that went for ~3 hours.
It's sort of a shame, because I liked getting raided by them for a change of pace (it's usually Mhaldor).
- (Eleusis): Ellodin says, "The Fissure of Echoes is Sarathai's happy place." - With sharp, crackling tones, Kyrra tells you, "The ladies must love you immensely." - (Eleusian Ranger Techs): Savira says, "Most of the hard stuff seem to have this built in code like: If adventurer_hitting_me = "Sarathai" then send("terminate and selfdestruct")." - Makarios says, "Serve well and perish." - Xaden says, "Xaden confirmed scrub 2017."
I thought Targ originally had the stance "if you're not with us and one of us, then you're against us" but now it appears that's not quite the case as they've become more tolerant over time. Although I am not complaining, nor do I care about how the CTF turned out since it has no impact on rogue life, but Targ has seemed to change from what it set out to be originally.
I guess actively trying to stop you from being able to impact Creation at all (whether to improve or remove others) isn't a good enough reason.
Honestly I know very little of new Targ, but from my position I'd just assume that good would be all about hindering and stopping evil as it's main purpose, even if it means letting other enemies succeed. Basically I think if ashtan/hashan/cyrene had of replaced Mhaldor in that position they would have done nothing, but the thought process would be "just stop evil at any costs!" If Sylvaria was mhaldorian or Targossian I'd RP that to the hilt, where either or I'd be fixated on stopping the other, eleusis/ashtan/hashan be damned
Comments
The CTF is a fun game, but does it really need any more of a reward than bragging rights, maybe some sort of shiny statue for the city.
Targossas is (vaguely) an ideological enemy of Eleusis (because it's a city, because Deucora blasted a hole in the ER, blah blah). Not the other way around. We're enemies of convenience. Unless Targ suddenly decides nuking the forests on the daily is what is best for Creation, the Eleusis-Targ relationship will likely never be as horribly irreconcilable as the Eleusis-Mhaldor relationship.
What about the Eleusians who accepted the help/offer?
Yeah, there's a historical basis for them winning if they help each other... And Mhaldor/Ashtan were basically completely unbeatable when they were together, yet they drifted apart based on conscious decisions made by the players that that wasn't good for the game and made for less interesting RP. Part of the annoyance here is that Targossas only pays lipservice to the unspoken agreement of 'every city for itself' that's been the norm for years.
Whoa. Whoa. Whoa, bro. We totally tried to Breathrain/holobomb one of your hills. Let's not take our ineptitude for a lack of hate.
Smugness, on part of any faction, toward any other faction, is a dull and predictable reaction. Inevitable, perhaps, but boring.
I threw that eye sigil. Owned you.
As for the rest of the complaints about OOC boundaries and shit, well, I'll pretty much just echo what @Halos said. Whether or not it was an asshole thing to do OOCly, it was a perfectly acceptable move by IC standards.
And @Aegoth, Eleusis isn't an enemy. More accurately, Eleusis sees us as an enemy, but we see them essentially as people trying to do the right thing and going about it in a mildly wrong way. Unlike Mhaldor who we see as a group of people trying to do the right thing (technically the 1st Truth is about growth of creation and all, for those who didn't know) but going about it an incredibly wrong and screwed up way that does more harm than good. Hence why it would be seen as a lesser evil to let Eleusis win rather than let Mhaldor win.
It's CTF, which is a game. It's not like it's "Ideologically pure City-versus-City conflict." People've always done slightly questionable things during Y700 events that really shouldn't ever be taken as the measure of a City's actual stance/position. I'm one hundred percent fine with Targossas helping Mhaldor lose a CTF. Wouldn't be okay with Targossas fighting a war for Eleusis (which it hasn't, and won't).
And it's funny to see that some of you, whom I very distinctly remember have taken dives to not gain points in order to just mess with others' chances to win CTFs throughout the year, whining so hard about the shoe being on the other foot. Pretty much everyone here, in some alt or another, I'm sure, has actually done that to another faction, so, forreal, take it easy.
Arguing about whether a motivation is acceptable or not isn't going to be particularly beneficial, because we all play characters in different factions. Perspective is highly important. I'm getting that from Mhaldor's perspective it was entirely unjustifiable IC because they don't see Mhaldor as being any more of an enemy to Targossas than Eleusis. Targossas doesn't really seem to get how it isn't obvious that Eleusis is far less of an enemy compared to Mhaldor.
The thing is, arguing about what's right and wrong isn't going to get anywhere. Sometimes it's best to just agree to disagree, and there doesn't seem like there's going to be any changing Mhaldor's mind or Targossas' mind. And that's okay. I just hope they don't think it's out of OOC hatred or anything like that, it's fine if they think the reasoning is flawed, though.
I think that believing people hate you/your faction OOCly would be really unhealthy, and that it would probably lead to behavior that isn't particularly great. At the end of the day it's important to remember that it's just a game, and try not to feel like IC actions mean ill OOC feelings, much less were motivated by such. It's probably naive to hope that the majority of such a small community can be friends, but at the very least I hope there aren't any lingering feelings of OOC animosity.
i'm a rebel
Whoever dropped all those holocausts while phased, they really hurt! And I hope I will never find myself in the same room as Jarrod and Crixos. They locked me so fast that I did not even have the chance to run.
But srs, there's really nothing else left to discuss. The divine of Targ at least support it, I imagine Eleusian ones don't give a damn, ours is busy building a brothel deep in the Inferno, and Mhaldor will just have to try for their first CTF win another time.
Edit: I am all for discussion of crazy skills and logs, mind. I wish I had more time to play with things. I didn't even get to check out much except that I have 44% devotion left still.
Edit edit: I'm so tired, what is english.
That love soon might end You are unbreaking
And be known in its aching Though quaking
Shown in this shaking Though crazy
Lately of my wasteland, baby That's just wasteland, baby
..especially not Tesha.
I forgot I could evade out of gravehands in the "I love you" log from Tharos, too. Actually, I forgot I could evade repeatedly. I guess dirge went to my head a bit, because I was having far too much fun making gravehands go away.
- With sharp, crackling tones, Kyrra tells you, "The ladies must love you immensely."
- (Eleusian Ranger Techs): Savira says, "Most of the hard stuff seem to have this built in code like: If adventurer_hitting_me = "Sarathai" then send("terminate and selfdestruct")."
- Makarios says, "Serve well and perish."
- Xaden says, "Xaden confirmed scrub 2017."
Results of disembowel testing | Knight limb counter | GMCP AB files
Cascades of quicksilver light streak across the firmament as the celestial voice of Ourania intones, "Oh Jarrod..."
OOCly, great for them. More conflict is great.
ICly, who gives a damn? They're pissed off that a river was diverted, some forest may have been destroyed, and we're building with bricks and stone and other materials rather than living in a tree. When you're opposing three factions that are trying to pervert the very nature of Creation that sort of pales in comparison, especially when their attacks don't actually work against your goal at all.
Results of disembowel testing | Knight limb counter | GMCP AB files
Cascades of quicksilver light streak across the firmament as the celestial voice of Ourania intones, "Oh Jarrod..."
It's sort of a shame, because I liked getting raided by them for a change of pace (it's usually Mhaldor).
- With sharp, crackling tones, Kyrra tells you, "The ladies must love you immensely."
- (Eleusian Ranger Techs): Savira says, "Most of the hard stuff seem to have this built in code like: If adventurer_hitting_me = "Sarathai" then send("terminate and selfdestruct")."
- Makarios says, "Serve well and perish."
- Xaden says, "Xaden confirmed scrub 2017."
@Mhaldor bring it! We're hardened logosmas grief veterans.