Welcome to the Achaea Forums! Please be sure to read the Forum Rules.

City novicehood

2456

Comments

  • TahquilTahquil Member Posts: 4,340 @@ - Legendary Achaean
    I think if this put in you might as well demote Houses to High Clans, since that pretty much all they'll be/are right now anyway.

    The reasons Houses work in Mhaldor is that no matter if your Naga or Congregation all the Houses Compliment each other to work for the greater goal of the city. A Lot of the novice tasks (when I was there) had to do with the history of the city, dealing with the philosophy of a city etc. etc.

    Nearly all other houses are self-centred. The deal only in what is relevant to them without asking a novice to learn about the city they are based in alongside house ideals.

    My solution would be to offer up mini history quests task for each city a novice could undertake if they wished so it can better underline why this city is how it is and the tenets it adheres to.. And so on. If you do implement 'cities before houses' plan I'ld demote ever house to a high clan because that's all they'll end up being.
    Halos
  • JacenJacen Member Posts: 2,305 @@ - Legendary Achaean
    Sarapis said:

    The proposed solution reminds me too much of autoclass - a few guilds had problems in the way they gated access to class so, instead of dealing with them, the entire system was thrown out and we got autoclass. 

    You're barking up the wrong tree there I'm afraid. Autoclass was one of the best decisions I ever made in regards to Achaea, and the numbers are unequivocal. More people converted from newbies to regular players, those regular players played longer on average, and players in general spent more in general post-autoclass. 
    Is this an indication that we're reverting back to autoclass?

    If yes, I think the this proposed system would merge very nicely. Newbie chooses a city (and thus an overarching philosophy) and a class. Newbie gets oriented to the game, learns a bit about what it'll take to get involved in combat, economics, politics, the arts, theft, infiltration, etc. Newbie chooses the House that best fits the way he wants to play the game. Smooth transition from allowing the player to decide his faction, his class, and then later, the manner in which he advances the philosophy. 

    If no, I imagine this could very well decrease newbie retention rate. Allowing the newbie to choose a class and city initially but not a House would give the impression that choosing a House is a bigger decision, and that the newbie will need to do some reading/researching to choose which he wants to play the most. In actuality, however, there wouldn't even be a choice at all. Even if the newbie doesn't spend many lessons in class skills before picking a House ( regardless of the return on lessons for a class change ), once the newbie finds out that he can't play <insert class here> in the way that he wants too, I imagine he would quit rather than reestablish his character as a different class or member of a different city.
    image
  • AgravainAgravain Member Posts: 114 ✭✭✭ - Distinguished
    Do we not already have autoclass? How can we revert back to it?
  • EldEld Member Posts: 3,946 @@ - Legendary Achaean
    edited April 2013
    Agravain said:
    Do we not already have autoclass? How can we revert back to it?
    I assume he means reverting back to "full" autoclass, meaning that all houses accept all classes (maybe with some citywide restrictions, such as Mhaldorian houses not taking Devo users, forestals being restricted to Eleusis, etc).
    Jespar
  • JacenJacen Member Posts: 2,305 @@ - Legendary Achaean
    Lol, I thought that's what autoclass meant. You kids and your damn terminology nowadays.
    image
    Averi
  • SenaSena Member Posts: 3,957 @@ - Legendary Achaean
    Autoclass is the current system of gaining class. You don't have to join a guild to get a class, and you don't have to pass novicehood in a guild to get the third skill and learn to trans.
  • JacenJacen Member Posts: 2,305 @@ - Legendary Achaean
    Oh. Well that thingy where you can join any House as any class. That's what I meant.
    image
  • NakariNakari Member Posts: 596 ✭✭✭✭✭ - Grand Achaean
    edited April 2013
     the more I think about this idea, the more I like it. There is probably nothing in terms of basic features that can not be taught by a city mate, as all classes at the really low levels are fairly similar (similar enough that most people could easily explain the most basic of skills). And even if mechanical mentorship is saved for the house, I feel like some sort of unofficial mentorship could easily be established through the cities to make sure that there are people directly interacting with newcomers. 

    I also agree that this might be able to offer the potential (and maybe should), for decreasing the limits on class per house per city. While I agree that was a good change overall, if a system was in place so that new players would be more likely to have an identity set for their characters before choosing a house to join, then there might well be fewer problems with allowing a little bit of overlap (certainly not the chaos that there was before). I don't know, I don't feel strongly about that particular point, and there's another thread for that anyways.

    Still, it sounds, for all the discussed reasons, that this could be really good if implemented well. At the very least it could probably make houses more of something that you join because of the ideals and such, and not just because they are there and you will have no idea how to do things if you don't

  • IocunIocun Member Posts: 3,506 @@ - Legendary Achaean
    edited April 2013
    Nevermind.
  • AveriAveri Member Posts: 555 ✭✭✭✭✭ - Grand Achaean
    edited April 2013
    I like @Blujixapug's idea of city novice orientations being automated. If this happened, i'd support the OP.  Our house already has enough newcomers to deal with. Just thinking about expanding that to a city-wide thing is well... headache-y.  Novices are time consuming and expensive and without a house loyalty behind it, I'd be much less inclined to spend like 6-9 hours directing them through scrolls, shops, hunting, reflexes and such. If the city orientation system is set in, I think a new novice introduction system is required as well. 

    Edit: also, it might be helpful to give the novice more items during the trial of rebirth, such as their hunting weapon like in Lusternia. It'd just make things less confusing.
    Commission List: Aesi, Kenway, Shimi, Kythra, Trey, Sholen .... 5/5 CLOSED
    I will not draw them in the order that they are requested... rather in the order that I get inspiration/artist block.
  • DraukaDrauka Member Posts: 243 ✭✭✭ - Distinguished
    I like the idea but it's not going to be pleasant for many people. 

    It does stink when you want to play a class and think you may try out a city, and you join a house with no one around. In Mhaldor, the city channel is dead except for higher ups saying something very randomly or summoning of all citizens to the gates.

    It's much more welcoming to have a whole city of people around and then decide on a class.

    I just hope that people will help newbies on city channels, because one of the things I personally don't like about Achaea is feeling so isolated and alone in the game at times, which isn't so much an issue now (But I haven't played in a week due to real-life work and moving), but it does stink. I want to play as a cool race and class and all that, but I always want to play with other players, too.

    Even with all the introduction and information about how to play the game, the new user still needs to not feel alone or a bother. If city chatting can do that, then that's awesome.
  • EldEld Member Posts: 3,946 @@ - Legendary Achaean
    It still seems to me that one of the easiest ways to start to address the problem of no one in a House being around to help novices would be to add an announcement to the city when a novice joins through the Trial. That way, they'll at least likely get some interaction with citymates (even if it's just a few greetings on CT), and helpful citizens might think to check what house the person's in, and whether they might need some help with the basics if no one else from that house is around. Alternatively, you could modify the notice that novice aides get when a novice of one of their house's accepted classes finishes the trial to also notify them when any novice in their city joins.

    @Morro's comment about a need for CHELP scrolls for each class could be addressed by a single scroll in which each house lists the HHELPs they want their novices to read; rogues would still be out of luck, but not significantly more so than currently. Newbs spending all their lessons on Survival would be addressed by the proposal of allowing free full resets during novicehood (I'd maybe suggest up to level 30 for that, just to be on the safe side).

    As far as the issue of the apparent confusion of joining both a city and a house initially, it might help to add a few lines about the relationship between the two, and pointing out that most houses will only accept members from one city. Currently, they're treated as pretty distinct, with the relationship not being clear, and while HOUSE LIST shows which city each house is based in, the significance of that is not very clear.
  • NyboeNyboe Member Posts: 83 ✭✭ - Stalwart
    edited April 2013
    Cities are too big to deal with city novicehood. Like if I was a newbie I wouldn't want to ask insane/newbie questions on the city channel where the entire city can hear me and judge me. A lot of people are not willing to help newbies because they don't see the rewards are worth the time it takes to help a newbie.

    Maybe instead of bringing the burden on to the entire city, rather give a better incentive for mentors? Like right now mentors just get some bonus exp when they hunt with their proteges and they can learn 20 lessons at a time as opposed to 15. These incentives feel rather weak to me. An idea for an incentive could be where if the protege became a mentor himself(by playing 300 hours) or if the protege got out of House novice hood the mentor could get a house/city favor and some credits.

    And to prevent this from being abused maybe limit to each person have a max of 3 proteges at once.
  • KyrraKyrra AustraliaMember Posts: 4,848 @@ - Legendary Achaean
    What @Nyboe mentioned is something that I struggle with sometimes. I don't like to bother people and try my best to figure out things on my own because I don't like being a bother - but some of that stems to a lot of rushed experiences in Houses where I have to read through a library of scrolls while someone is waiting to give an hour long orientation ;)

    The role of the Ambassador Ministry in any city, not only involves welcoming new citizens, but looking after novices as well. While I can understand the reluctance to speak on the city channel sometimes - I know Ashtan doesn't really like random chatter - anyone can check AIDES AMBASSADOR to see the list of people in the Ministry and they should all be willing to help you.

    When few folk are on, I actually welcome new citizens, and send them a tell to read the relevant city scrolls and the syntax to check for Ambassador aides so they're aware of who they should be talking to. Most of the time, they come back to ask me questions, which is fine because I like helping people anyways. There's a system in place.
    (D.M.A.): Cooper says, "Kyrra is either the most innocent person in the world, or the girl who uses the most innuendo seemingly unintentionally but really on purpose."

    Sylvance
  • MorroMorro Member Posts: 93 ✭✭✭ - Distinguished
    @Eld I was under the impression that novices would be without a House and have no access to HHELPs initially.
  • NyboeNyboe Member Posts: 83 ✭✭ - Stalwart
    edited April 2013
    Yeah I agree. The Ambassador Ministry does help city novices. When I first played the game I didn't even know anything about ambassador aides.
    All I did was pester Romeo and Juliet and they told me to join a house and I would get help. And indeed I did get help once I joined a house. But I had no idea that their were ambassador aides to help novices. No scroll or anyone mentioning this.

    Maybe make the Ambassador Ministry more open to the newbies. Like have an opening message which gets sent to the newbie who just got citizenship into the city and it lists all the ambassador aides online in the city and the newbie can then send tells to the ambassador aides if they need help.

    As an ambassador aide I would actually be glad if newbies starting sending me tells asking for help because it would save me work from having to find newbies who need help which believe it or not is half the work.
  • KyrraKyrra AustraliaMember Posts: 4,848 @@ - Legendary Achaean
    I know there's a message for people inducted through the city denizens but I don't think there's a message for those that join through the Trial.
    (D.M.A.): Cooper says, "Kyrra is either the most innocent person in the world, or the girl who uses the most innuendo seemingly unintentionally but really on purpose."

  • EldEld Member Posts: 3,946 @@ - Legendary Achaean
    Morro said:
    @Eld I was under the impression that novices would be without a House and have no access to HHELPs initially.
    I meant that as an alternative to delaying the choice of a house (or at least as something that could be done now, without waiting for the time it would take to implement a full city novicehood program).
  • EldEld Member Posts: 3,946 @@ - Legendary Achaean
    Kyrra said:
    I know there's a message for people inducted through the city denizens but I don't think there's a message for those that join through the Trial.
    That's correct.
  • IdelisaIdelisa Member Posts: 385 ✭✭✭✭ - Eminent
    I think that this COULD be a benefit, only if class requirements were removed from most Houses.  After all, I would be very discouraged if I became a Sylvan, became very excited about the Sent soldier like attitude only to find out that I had no choice but to become a scholar.  

    It would be very discouraging.  Although even now it's discouraging, we have the benefit of becoming 'attached' to the people in our House to at least make it a little less difficult to accept that we literally don't have any choice. 

    If novices could join houses because they agreed with the values and tenants, it could be really exciting!
    image
    SylvanceAnatral
  • MishgulMishgul ROTHERHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAMMember Posts: 5,364 @@ - Legendary Achaean

    Then you realise that sylvan is terrible in ranged combat and you sit vigouring people all day (PUN).

    Class restrictions are a grey area, because a lot of houses use abilities for RP reasons, and then you dilute them by spreading them around.

    And then houses become even less important and you end up just having a city without houses and two clans, for scholars and for warriors or something, and then you have a bigger community with the archetypical groups filling the voids and various people being isolated and alienated due to attitudes/beliefs/timezones and nothing has really changed.

    -

    One of the symptoms of an approaching nervous breakdown is the belief that one's work is terribly important

    As drawn by Shayde
    hic locus est ubi mors gaudet succurrere vitae
    XliAveriIdelisa
  • PrythePrythe Member Posts: 472 ✭✭✭✭ - Eminent
    Oy.

    In the grander scheme of things, Houses were the evolution of Guilds. Traditionally people were born in a City, then perhaps later joined a Guild,. so, in that manner, it does make sense when we compare it to our real world parallels. 

    I think more would have to be reworked however. If you have classless people coming to Cities, they can learn basics, but as mentioned upthread, newbiekick their way through Minia?

    If they choose a class, they gain skills, but then they are forced into a particular House because of the City/House restrictions. Open it up? Would work for me, and would be very interesting. We could skip the Novice part of our House stuff, and move right to Apprentice things.

    All THAT said - it is difficult enough to keep everybody on the same track in a House as to Novices and expectations and who can and should Aide (and will there be some sort of "testing" to get them to whatever allows them to be qualified to join a House?) .... I think it would be more than the difficult transition which yes, we would ultimately get past, but into the realm of "A good idea, but not viable in the long run."




    - To love another person is to see the face of G/d
    - Let me get my hat and my knife
    - It's your apple, take a bite
    - Don't dream it ... be it


    SylvanceIdelisa
  • DraekarDraekar Member Posts: 290 ✭✭✭✭ - Eminent
    edited April 2013

    I don't know how or if this would work for other cities and I won't pretend to comment for them.

    @Sarapis this is the single best thing you could see done for Targossas. I could talk all day about why this would work and how much it would benefit the new City, so I'll just list the first three thoughts I had.

    1. One central city training school/academy that keeps the entire City/Houses/Orders on the exact same page and working together around the exact same understandings and ideals. It could be it's own org perhaps like the Church was, but be setup solely to set the foundation for everyone who enters the City and teaches the ideals that we all must adhere to.

    2. The repetitive training of novices is a bitch and kills everyone eventually. Sharing this task across all the Houses/City/Orders ensures we can pool our teachers into sharing the load rather than trying to duplicate efforts in every House. It will of course give far better coverage of timezones too.

    3. Unity. Everyone will have the exact same ideals and focus and each House can then be about adding to that as a specialisation rather than having different or competing ideals (one of the top five things that killed Shallam that was) So House one can take those ideals and train fighters, another House can take those ideals and train librarians, another can take those ideals and train shopkeepers or whatever etc etc. Likewise the orders can draw from the same pool and train better god servants.

    Downside:

    I do feel class RP might suffer as Houses did have a strong focus on that as part of the novice training. Houses could set a strong culture around classes and I am not sure how that would work in a central pool, and especially with the possibility of multi-class Houses that I have seen discussed. Knights and Serpents and well most classes have really amazing RP arcs, history and tradition across all of Achaea and I am not sure I'd enjoy Targossas missing out on that side of things if we did become the testing ground for a new arrangement.

    HalosKakotas
Sign In to Comment.