THE BEST

Arador

Caine, Khoraji, Septerra, Luggs back in the day. 

Cooper

Luggs wasn't anything more than an artied scrub. Also he smelled bad. 

Jarrel

Luggs was much more successful at infernal than you ever were. He was vivisecting people with battle-axes while you were playing horkval, putrefaction with 251 249 rapiers and failing at life.

Cooper

Whoooooosh.

Jarrel

sounds about right

Jaizsur

People keep leaving out Nimby-- probably the best system-less fighter of all time.

I think Poergh is getting less credit than she deserves-- Poergh was incredibly accomplished for a long time, even back when she was on a satellite connection.

Anyway, I think a lot of the "top" fighters were only so because of the number of artefacts that they had. Judging based purely on skill I wouldn't want to particularly mess with Santar or Poergh in a fair fight. Thankfully, Poergh and I were on the same team and Santar was alright with one eye on him at all times.

Triak

Luggs?  Psh...he never amounted to anything. 

Tranquility

Sarapis said:

The eras aren't comparable but I'm throwing in Isildur, Mausolus, Nimos, Tranquility.

Thank you! I would like to mention that Nimos, my friend in real life, is the one who introduced me to Achaea. 

Atalkez

Solid rezz Tranquility. I wonder if these lists changed since this thread?

Connell

@Tranquility