It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
And any other membership bonus ideas you might have!
The answer is highly dependent on your goals, artefacts, where you bash, and talismans.
I don't care as much about experience as I do min-maxing damage. I get less experience overall, but more gold/talismans.
If you are going for Dragon, always get the experience.
If you want experience more than gold/talismans, choose experience.